Accountants are often criticized for not having an economic perspective. It has been continually debated whether U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) should allow companies to report economic assets on their balance sheet. There are two major problems if the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) allows economic assets to be valued. First, financial statements will lose their comparability and verifiability. Second, managers will have more opportunities to misguide and misdirect investors. Due to these problems, economic assets should not be added to the balance sheets.
The conceptual framework is a set of fundamentals and objectives that improve financial reporting. Two qualitative characteristics that financial reporting would lose if economic assets are journalized would be comparability and verifiability (Switter, Leisenring, Lott, and Alqamoussi, 2014). Every company is unique, and each would have drastic differences in their economic assets like brand value, operating expertise, and brain power (Aston, 2002). Companies’ statements would no longer be comparable. There isn’t a single, correct way to value economic assets; therefore, financial statements wouldn’t be verifiable.
GAAP is a rules-based system that gives managers very little discretion. As mentioned before, economic assets are extremely hard to value. Managers could manipulate the amount reported, thus inflating the value of their company (J. Doyle, personal communication, September 30, 2014). By reporting fraudulent figures on the balance sheet, in the long-run investors would be hurt. Financial markets would be inefficient and unstable, possibly leading to a stock market crash.
The financial statements of the company do not need to have the economic assets reported. While this would look better for the company, it is not worth the negative effect on financial statements or the possibility of managers’ fraudulent activity. Reporting the economic assets in the financial statements wouldn’t even affect the market price because the market already adjusts for them. Even though economic assets are important for decision making, they shouldn't be reported on the balance sheet.
References
Aston, A. (2002, August 26). Brainpower on the balance sheet. BusinessWeek, 110-111.
Switter, J., Leisenring, J., Lott, R., & Alqamoussi, J. (2014, July 3). Conceptual framework. Retrieved from http: //www.fasb.org/cs/ContentServer?pagename=FASB%2FFASBContent_C%2Fproject
UpdatePage&cid=900000011090